Sunday, August 31, 2008

IT 5130 - Cool Tools

ooVoo
http://www.oovoo.com/

“ooVoo is the next evolution in online communication — a remarkably easy way to have a face-to-face video chat with friends, family or colleagues, no matter where they are in the world.”

Yeah, if you have the right computer equipment…the bandwidth to handle the application…the security situation that allows you to have the tool…and a desire to be seen in your pajamas. I know it has applications for eLearning, but I see this more as a new toy for the ‘cool kids’, the people that get the latest iPod when their old one is only a year old.

TalkShoe
http://www.talkshoe.com/

“TalkShoe is a service that enables anyone to easily create, join, or listen to Live Interactive Discussions, Conversations, Podcasts and Audioblogs. These hosted Community Calls can be discussions, conversations, talk shows and podcasts. Recorded Community Calls can be listened to, downloaded, or subscribed to. And if your Community Call becomes popular, you can make money too.”

TalkShoe seem sort of like the eClass application we’re using at work. You may participate live and interact with other students and the teacher during the actual session. After the session, a recording is made available for those who were unable to attend live or may need to view the class again as a refresher. I can see this having a valuable contribution for online classes, but only from the participating student’s point of view. They could post a project on TalkShoe and have classmates check it out. I’m afraid that most universities would not want their course content available to one and all on the net.

Jott.com
http://jott.com/

“Jott makes creating and maintaining to-do lists simple - all it takes is one phone call. No need to wait till you get home to write down what you need to do, just call Jott, say the name of the list you want, and leave a message. Your voice message will be converted to text and added to that list for you.

In this age of text messaging and all the other PDA-type functions, who pays for this functionality? In monetary and in bandwidth terms? Whatever happened to keeping a notebook or a “To Do” list?

*sigh*

I don’t know…maybe I’m resistant to new technology, or perhaps I’ve fallen into the mindset of the government agency where I work. There are so many restrictions about connectivity, bandwidth and the tools that can be used on the baseline software load.

My audience is primarily lower ranking military personnel and government employees who are deploying into war zones overseas. I teach them to use tools that help keep them safe on the front lines and the rest of us safe at home.

We struggle with getting the bandwidth for the essential tools they need, not to mention all of the new ‘cool’ tools that are continually coming out in the commercial world.

I know I need to see the ‘big picture’ and not focus on my small slice of life. But, that’s where I am and that’s where I’m needed right now. I need to find tools and techniques that apply to *their* situation. We’re just now moving into eLearning, where folks who are forward deployed to war zones and overseas locations can participate in much-needed training, without taking the time and expense to travel back to the United States. That’s saving taxpayer’s money and that’s not a bad thing, from my point of view.

IT 5650 - Bernard Article

I haven’t had a stats class or a comparative analysis class, so most of it (the minutia of the analysis itself) didn’t make a lot of sense to me. In fact, this reading selection was quite painful to wade through.

However, the few points that did make it through my head were:

1. It’s really not what an instructor does with the instructional medium that counts, it’s what the learner does with the medium that is of importance. The medium at that point becomes not just transparent, but transformative and actually aids the learner in achieving their learning goals.

2. Using computer-mediated communication (CMC) may increase reflection and the development of better writing skills. It is also postulated that CMC can promote critical thinking skills.

3. “The results of this meta-analysis provide general support for the claim that effective DE depends on the provision of pedagogical excellence.” Well, DUH! In my mind, effective DE has always depended upon the quality of the instructional design. The media used to deliver the instruction is very important and can enhance (or detract) from the instructional message. However, if you don’t get the instructional message designed correctly, no amount of bells and whistles from the media will change that fact.

The other thing that gets me is the age of this article and its sources. Are there no more recent examples of empirical literature on the subject? We all know the field has changed substantially in just the past couple of years. Where are more recent studies?

Thursday, August 28, 2008

Technologically Challenged

So...here I am stewing about upcoming projects in *both* courses.

Create a data file in PDF?

Lest we forget, this is the same person that had issues trying to run DreamWeaver in 2001 and had to hand-code the online learning web site for the certification.

Interview a practitioner in eLearning?

What if I don't *know* any eLearning practitioners? And if I can find one, who in their right mind is gonna give some person off the street the time of day to talk to them?!?

*sigh*

Well, at least one problem *has* been solved. I've found a free, online convert your whatever documents into a PDF...and it works! Here's the link:

http://www.pdfonline.com/

I'll post this link to the 'cool tools' area of the courses...if I can ever find them again...

Sunday, August 24, 2008

IT 5650: "Bespoke" eLearning

Hhhmmm...ran across this term loads today while I was searching the internet. Seems to come mainly out of the UK and Canada. However, I couldn't find an actual definition.

I saw it connected most often with companies offering eLearning services. Any thoughts?

Saturday, August 23, 2008

IT 5130: PowerPoint is Evil…Tufte Needs a Nap!

After reading the Tufte article, I came to a startling conclusion:

Mr. Tufte obviously fronted money for Bill Gates when he was starting Microsoft, but sold out early because he didn’t believe the venture would fly. Now, he’s got sour grapes.

In Scott Rosenberg’s article “The Data Artist” (Salon, March 1997), he says, “It could be, too, that the big publishers unfairly pegged Tufte as a bit of a crank. His writing sometimes exhibits a curled-lip testiness toward its targets, and he's unafraid to wield the knife of the polemical critic.”
Ya think?!?

Seriously…I get what Tufte is saying. Many presenters across numerous fields rely too much on PowerPoint and its ability to make creating presentation materials *easy*, like a WYSIWYG editor. PowerPoint is not a suitable medium for presenting scientific and technical material. I *get* it.

But what about the responsibility of the presenter? Why rely on the templates from PowerPoint? You can be quite creative using the blank presentation model. It’s the designer’s ability and responsibility to coherently design and present their information using the PowerPoint medium, right?

Seriously, we’re looking at slideshows that *win awards*…doesn’t that say that designers can and do have a clue?

Regarding the NASA example, the engineers could have fine-tuned and presented their information in a more coherent manner. Tufte’s graphic where he "cleaned up the engineers’ information" proves that. It’s not PowerPoint’s fault that they chose not to do so. It actually sounds more like the engineers deliberately tried to minimize the bad news by hiding it in the lower hierarchy of the slides. That’s akin to criminal, in my mind.

BTW: I looked up Tufte’s term “Projector Operating System”. I could only find it five pages deep on Google, in reference to a specific projector, “In Focus multimedia projector operating system LP 740TM”. It was a manual for a projector.

That’s why I sincerely think Tufte’s term “Projector Operating System” is a tongue-in-cheek method for Tufte to call PowerPoint and Microsoft a “POS”. (See Scott Reosenberg’s reference above for Tufte's attitude.)

For a condensed version of this material, check out Tufte’s “PowerPoint is Evil” article in Wired magazine.
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/11.09/ppt2.html It condenses the material of our course article, makes most of the same points but omits the NASA information.

Wednesday, August 20, 2008

I miss threads!

Okay...I miss threads. This whole blogging thing seems overly complicated.

I've now created this blog, but how do I get back to it? What's the URL that I have to post? I can't really imagine that "http://www.blogger.com/post-create.g?blogID=6576933523110265669" is it...especially since there's a 'create' word in it.

I don't have high hopes that this will work for me. Perhaps it will and I will have had an attitude adjustment by tomorrow. ;-)